About Us

affordable insuranceIntegrity Personal Insurance is an Independent Insurance agency that was created to provide individuals and businesses with the assistance they needed to make the best decisions with their insurance. Since 2008 we have implemented a unique business model that makes the process of shopping insurance simple for our clients. We exist to serve the unique needs of individual and commercial clients who have been overlooked by an industry focused on “big business”. Our agency is contracted with over 75 different National insurance carriers. With one call we shop your insurance to get you the absolute best rates for the same coverage. There are no fees and no gimmicks. After you choose the carrier, we represent you as your local agent, offering you ongoing service and free renewal re-shops to ensure you are always getting the best price on insurance. Our average call-in saves around $700 on annual premiums.

We have remained consistent in our approach and have been blessed with the opportunity to help thousands of wonderful people with their affordable insurance while remaining small enough to appreciate each and every one. Our agency’ s name came from a verse in proverbs which states:

“A man of Integrity walks securely” – Proverbs 10:9

We believe that if we handle each customer with integrity that they will be able to provide the right protection for their families from whatever situations come. Whether you need help with your personal insurance, small business insurance, or just someone you can trust to give you a straight answer, Integrity Personal Insurance is here.

Meet Our Team

Lacey Fisher
Lacey Fisher

Administrative Team

Lee Siegel
Lee Siegel

Personal and Investment Property Insurance Advisor

Melissa Fruscella
Melissa Fruscella

Personal Lines Insurance Advisor

Patrice Texada
Patrice Texada

Personal Lines Insurance Provider

Kristi Dyer
Kristi Dyer

Client Service Manager

Kim Sheffield
Kim Sheffield

Client Services / Renewal Advisor

Lisa Hodges
Lisa Hodges
Casey Nelson
Casey Nelson

Agency Principal

Paola Cuellar
Paola Cuellar
Eddie Cuellar
Eddie Cuellar
  • Thanks again for your hard work — we are thankful to have found your company and are impressed with your quality, cost-effective services.

    Dawn T. Dawn T.
  • Kim was wonderful and has already taken care of my questions. Thanks for following up.

    Joann B. Joann B.
  • I’m really grateful that I found Melissa Fruscella and the other staff members! I literally prayed for an answer concerning getting another insurance provider after we were dropped by our previous provider. Not only did we get a better rate but the level of involvement we have completely transcends any other provider we’ve ever had, by light years! When it dawned on me to remember Dave Ramsey, it all fell into place. Nothing like knowing you’re doing the right thing, and I can literally thank God for intersecting out paths.

    Bill M. Bill M.
  • Thanks you so much. My experience with Integrity has been wonderful.

    Sue H. Sue H.
  • My husband and I both agree you are a great agent. We wish we found you sooner!

    Boni K. Boni K.
  • Thank you so much for helping me jump start my life in the insurance realm. I am more motivated now to keep full coverage and all perils due common sense. I enjoyed working with you and cannot wait to refer someone to you so they can also experience the JOY you brought to us! Feels great to be so young and insurance paid for a year! Couldn’t have done it without you, like lights down a dark stairway!

    Joseph P. Joseph P.
  • Safeco’s team has been real helpful and professional. We really appreciate this! When we renew in March/April, I will need your help to see if Safeco is still the best price going forward (even though I like their customer service so far).

    Belina C. Belina C.
  • Wonderful, THANK YOU so very much. You have been such a Blessing in this Time of struggle for my family. I truly believe GOD has lead us to your Company and I hope that through GOD’s continued mercy in our lives, we will continue to have a working relationship past our time of Retirement.

    Terrie Y. Terrie Y.
  • You are certainly not “my” secret, although you are such as asset to my clients, that honestly, I consider you a part of “my” team! It’s a win-win that you are so often able to significantly help my clients, & your caring and service are out the roof …

    Cindy G. Cindy G.
  • Both you and Reid have been knowledgable, responsive, and very professional individuals. I would always refer clients to you knowing how you treated me.

    John J. John J.

Connect With Us:

Our Insurance Companies

Don’t be shy

Drop us a line anytime, and we will respond to you as soon as possible

Contact Us

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Not readable? Change text.